BC’s LNG production goals are doable, but US-backed protests are mobilizing

Written By Tom Fletcher
Published

Can B.C. triple its LNG production by 2035, as Premier Lorne Doerkson promises? Current plans put the goal within reach even as more U.S.-backed protests begin mobilizing against any fast-tracking of projects.

B.C. voters are used to hearing lofty goals for future greenhouse gas reductions, typically for years ending in zero or five that are far in the future. Premier Lorne Doerkson’s targets to double B.C.’s liquefied natural gas production by 2032 and triple it by 2035 are significantly supported by ongoing developments, but some still await final investment decisions.

Others face organized opposition, similar to those that took place against the now-operational Coastal GasLink pipeline, which runs from northeastern B.C.’s gas fields to the North Coast.

With LNG Canada phase two now financed and Ksi Lisims LNG expected to go ahead—thanks to B.C.’s first sales agreement—Doerkson’s goal to double B.C.’s LNG output is within reach. Add to that, the smaller projects nearing completion, including Cedar LNG near Kitimat and Woodfibre near Squamish, and tripling output is also achievable.

LNG Canada phase two is the biggest project on the books and has been approved for construction by the Shell-led consortium that built the first phase. This will move the two LNG processing trains to four, with completion expected by the early 2030s. Its output capacity will go from the current 14 million tonnes per year to 28 million.

Phase two will require five additional compressor stations on the existing Coastal GasLink pipeline, so the existing pipe can supply what LNG Canada CEO Chris Cooper describes as one of the largest LNG export terminals in the world. It is a joint venture of Shell, PETRONAS, PetroChina, Mitsubishi Corp. and Korea Gas.

More LNG projects will follow

Ksi Lisims LNG awaits a final investment decision for its floating facility at Pearse Island, near the Nisga’a Nation community of Gingolx. Supplied by a second gas pipeline across northern B.C., Ksi Lisims is designed to produce 12 million tonnes per year, which would make it B.C.’s second largest LNG export terminal.

Ksi Lisims is billed as a “net zero” LNG producer, using electricity from the BC Hydro grid unlike the gas-fired power deployed by LNG Canada and most other major plants around the world. Owned by the Nisga’a Lisims Government, a group of Canadian gas producers called Rockies LNG Partners, and Houston-based Western LNG, Ksi Lisims LNG has secured a 20-year purchase agreement with SEFE (Securing Energy for Europe) of Germany.

Woodfibre LNG got a modest boost in its planned production Nov. 13 as it nears completion of another electric-drive LNG export terminal on a former pulp mill site near Squamish. Premier-elect Doerkson was on site to welcome a commitment from federal Energy and Natural Resources Minister Tim Hodgson to invest $200 million in expanded capacity, with Hodgson saying Woodfibre’s future low-carbon LNG production will help Ottawa get to its goal of doubling non-U.S. exports.

Woodfibre LNG was designed to produce 2.1 million tonnes a year, and federally-funded improvements to maximize efficiency bring it up to 2.6 million tonnes a year. Ottawa’s investment will also allow a second phase to be considered by investors Pacific Energy Corp. of Singapore and Calgary-based Enbridge, the latter of which owns 30 per cent.

Tilbury Island LNG terminal opened on the Fraser River between Delta and Richmond in 1971 to provide natural gas storage for high-demand heating days and gas system outages in Metro Vancouver. Its phase-one expansion, to be completed in 2028, includes a 46,000 cubic metre storage tank with capacity for a backup domestic supply, as well as, fuel for transportation, shipping (including BC Ferries) and overseas export.

FortisBC has embarked on a second phase of expansion to begin as early as 2027. A 142,400-cubic metre LNG storage tank will increase storage capacity by 2.5 times. An additional liquefaction capacity of up to 2.5 million tonnes a year will serve emerging markets, including ships converting from semi-refined bunker oil. The phase two project is supplied by the FortisBC pipeline network, and includes a 2022 partnership with the Musqueam Indian Band.

If it goes to plan, Tilbury will bring LNG production close to Doerkson’s target of tripling output by 2035.

Cedar LNG on the Douglas Channel at Kitimat is more than 70 per cent complete and scheduled to begin production in late 2028. Majority-owned by the Haisla Nation, with co-owners Pembina Pipeline Corp., the floating terminal will be supplied by a branch line from the Coastal GasLink pipeline that feeds LNG Canada. It is designed to produce three million tonnes a year of LNG for export, with a floating import facility also underway in South Korea.

Kanata LNG is another proposed floating terminal considering its options in the Prince Rupert region. If it can work out supply, site location and financing, the project could produce up to 12 million tonnes per year. Kanata announced Nov. 16 it has signed an agreement with Hanwha Ocean of South Korea for its next phase of development.

Summit Lake PG LNG is B.C.’s only proposed inland site. If it goes it ahead, the project would be located north of Prince George, with liquefaction and rail loading facilities for up to 2.7 million tonnes per year. Close to existing natural gas production infrastructure, Summit Lake would ship LNG by specialized containers on CN Rail for export from Prince Rupert.

One proposal that has made little progress is Kitimat LNG, led by Chevron at Bish Cove. It was one of 19 proposed projects on the B.C. government’s list in 2017.

Another stalled project is Pacific Northwest LNG, the PETRONAS-led project at Lulu Island near Port Edward. Abandoned amid salmon habitat concerns, PETRONAS, a leading Malaysian energy giant, instead joined LNG Canada.

Steelhead LNG remains active in Vancouver after having tried a series of locations on Vancouver Island. Its latest efforts have focused on legal action against Cedar LNG and its backers over intellectual property issues related to floating LNG technology.

Data centres compete for B.C. and Alberta gas production

Long-term supply of B.C. natural gas is not in question.

B.C.’s Energy Mines and Petroleum Resources Minister Larry Neufeld, a petroleum engineer representing Peace River South, has pointed out that with the province’s Montney shale in production and limited exploration done in the Liard and Horn River formations farther north, 300 years of supply is a modest estimate.

The emergence of artificial intelligence data centres has changed the natural gas market, long characterized by low prices and abundant supply. Alberta has charged ahead with plans for gas-fired data centres, led by a $13 billion “campus” north of Edmonton proposed by Meta Platforms, owner of Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. The Globe and Mail reports that Alberta now has more than 140 data centre proposals on the books.

The election of Doerkson’s B.C. Conservatives calls into question the NDP government’s policy that new data centres would have to bid for BC Hydro power, which already has a long waiting list of industrial electricity applications. A change to the NDP’s CleanBC program could open the door to new gas-fired power plants.

Demand in Alberta also includes oil sands production. TC Energy estimates a 25 per cent increase in power use over five years due to oil sands expansion, data centres and other consumer demand. The company has proposed a new 48-inch pipeline from B.C. gas fields, east to the oil sands region at Fort McMurray to serve new demand.

International protests targeting B.C. gas, Alberta oil

Anti-resource activism in B.C. has long been funded by U.S. interests. The election of Doerkson on a promise to aggressively play B.C.’s resource cards has led to an increase in protest activity, led by U.S.-based environmental groups partnered with indigenous representatives in B.C.

Sierra Club BC is currently running a fundraising Facebook video warning that the BC Conservatives intend to “double down on unsustainable clearcutting, expand polluting oil and gas projects,” and avoid species-at-risk protections.

“Their promise to repeal DRIPA also threatens indigenous sovereignty and progress that has been made on indigenous-led conservation efforts,” the video’s narrator says.

The Squamish Nation is a partner and regulator for the Woodfibre plant, and the Nisga’a and Haisla Nations are majority owners in the northern LNG projects. Nonetheless, outside organizations and some B.C. activist Indigenous groups portray First Nations communities as being against these and other resource developments.

San Francisco-based Stand.Earth is behind another international effort that recently staged a news conference in Ottawa featuring John Ridsdale, a West’suwet’en Nation hereditary chief who goes by the name Na’moks. For several years, Risdale led protests against the Trans Mountain and Coastal GasLink pipeline.

On Oct. 8, Ridsdale was with Stand.Earth was on Parliament Hill to protest Bill C-39, the Mark Carney government’s bill to streamline project approvals. Alongside Ridsdale was veteran Cree activist Clayton Thomas-Muller and representatives of Colombian Amazon tribes, who were flown in for the occasion. Speakers also demanded reparations for past industrial developments, and called for “free, prior and informed consent” to all industrial developments in “so-called Canada.”

Federal Conservative MP Ellis Ross, a former chief councillor for Haisla Nation and current shadow minister for the Environment, has long pushed back against environmenal organizations trying to interfere with natural resource projects involving Indigenous communities. Ross also said activist Indigenous groups do not represent Indigenous communities in matters of Aboriginal rights and title, and so cannot speak for them on matters of consent. Ross is calling on the prime minister to clarify the consultation process around major projects.